Lesson 05 · Threads Academy
Seven post formats
A format is not a template you drop words into. It is the shape of a conversation: what the reader does once they have finished. The seven below cover almost everything an account that grows on replies publishes.
01
Why the format decides more than the topic
A post on Threads lives on replies. What carries it past your own followers is a reaction, and people do not react to "useful" — they react to something they can agree with or argue against.
So a format is not "how to lay the text out". It is what the reader does after the last line. An opinion asks for agreement. A question asks for an answer. A mistake asks to be recognised. A post that asks for nothing collects views and stops there.
Seven shapes below, one live post each. The letters on the lines are the breakdown: the same letter sits under the post and says what that line is doing there.
The example posts are in English, and that is not an accident: an account is written in the language of its GEO, not yours. What transfers is the shape, not the words. The account itself and the numbers under the posts are invented: they illustrate the format, not its result.
02
Format 1. Opinion
The cheapest to produce and the most common in the feed of accounts that work. Two lines with a position in them.
961381.7K
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapethesisreasonroom to argue
- AThe thesis is the first line. The reader has your position before they decide whether to read on.
- BA reason somebody can disagree with. That is the invitation: half the replies will start with "not only that".
CarefulDo not soften it. "Sometimes some beginners lose for various reasons" is not a position, and there is nothing to reply to.
03
Format 2. Market update
Everybody has the same news. The value is in what you are looking at.
6471890
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapeeventtwo or three observationsquestion
- AThe event in one line. After it the reader is inside your head rather than inside the news.
- BThe question at the end turns a summary into a conversation, and gives the replies a reason to exist.
CarefulIf you can delete the first line and nothing changes, the post had no observations in it.
Retelling
3261
That is a wire feed. There is no author in it and nothing to argue with.
Interpretation
4739540
Same fact, but there is an angle — and somebody to disagree with it.
04
Format 3. Mistake
Teaches, shows experience and builds the character at once. It only works in the first person.
1822443.1K
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapeyour mistakewhat it costwhat you do now
- A"I", not "beginners". A mistake in the first person does not lecture, and nobody wants to dispute it — they want to add their own.
- BA concrete action instead of a moral. "Kept no notes" can be checked; "lacked discipline" cannot.
CarefulA mistake with no price is a list of tips. Say what it cost — time, money, a month with nothing to show.
05
Format 4. Contrarian angle
The window of attention is already open — everyone is on the topic. You arrive from another side.
5746620
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapeeveryone says Xthe interesting part is elsewherewhich part
- AThe shared position first, so the reader recognises the conversation they are already in.
- BThe turn, in one line. Without it this is one more post about the same thing.
CarefulContrarian for its own sake shows in the first line. With no observation of your own, use format 2 instead.
06
Format 5. Question
The most underrated one: it collects replies and hands you the topics of your next posts for free.
21319430
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapea choice of twono right answer
- AA choice of two, not "what do you think?". Few people answer an open question; many pick a side, because picking is easy.
- BBoth options have to be reasonable. The moment one looks correct, the replies stop.
The replies under a post like this are research: the audience's pains, their words, the objections Telegram will have to answer later. Write them down.
CarefulNo more than one a day. An account that only asks never claims anything, and there is nothing to follow it for.
07
Format 6. Open loop
A promise you keep today. The one format here that frequency ruins.
78921.1K
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapewhat you didwhat surprised youwhen you'll show it
- AA concrete action over a concrete stretch. "Tested a few things" is not a loop, it is noise.
- BA deadline close enough to check. People check "today"; nobody waits for "soon".
CarefulIf every post ends in "more later", the mechanic turns into bait — and on the third one the reader stops coming back.
08
Format 7. Mini-thread
One topic, five touches. The reader stays with you longer, and every reply of yours lifts the thread again.
- mia.navarro.markets15h FollowMost traders don't have a strategy problem.They have a record-keeping problem.
1492052.4K
- mia.navarro.markets15hIf you can't say why you entered, you can't tell a bad trade from a bad process.
2234610
- mia.navarro.markets15hLast month I went back through 40 entries. 12 had no reason written down. Nine of those were losses.
4158830
- mia.navarro.markets15hThe fix took two minutes per trade: one line before the entry, one after the exit.
1827540
- mia.navarro.markets15hWhat do you write down before you enter?
9611290
Reply to mia.navarro.markets
Shapethesisexplanationexampleconclusionquestion
- AEvery reply is a post in your own thread, not a paragraph. They are read one at a time and any of them can be answered.
- BThe last one is a question. A thread without it ends; a thread with it continues in somebody else's hands.
CarefulMore than five is an article, and few finish one. If the topic does not fit in five, it is a topic for Telegram.
09
When a post looks written by AI
What gives a finance account away is not the topic but the evenness. Tick what is true of your last week.
AI earns its place on research, variations, structure and editing. The position, the observation and the author's own words are not its job — and they are what separates an account from a feed.
0/6
10
Mini-task: five posts
Take your niche and write one post in each of the first five formats. Open loop and mini-thread come next week, when you have something to show.
Drop in a shape:
Five posts is one week at a calm pace. In a week look at which of the five collected replies, and repeat the shape rather than the post.